Marketplace vs own store: sell on Amazon or on your own site?

Marketplaces bring buyers but take a large cut and keep the customer. Your own store keeps margin and data but needs traffic. How to choose, or run both.

By Sohail Hussain21 November 20265 min read

Sell on a marketplace when buyers already search there for products like yours and you need sales quickly. Build your own store when margin, repeat customers and control of your brand matter more than immediate volume. Most product brands end up doing both: the marketplace for discovery and volume, their own store for repeat buyers and full-margin sales. The deciding numbers are your margin after marketplace fees, and what it costs you to bring a buyer to your own site instead.

How do a marketplace and your own store compare?

Marketplace (Amazon, Flipkart, Noon)Your own store
BuyersAlready there and searchingYou have to bring them
FeesReferral fee per sale plus closing, fulfilment and storage feesPayment fee of 2 to 3 percent plus platform costs
Customer dataHeld by the marketplace; emails maskedYours, with consent to market
Brand presentationStandard listing templateYour design, your content
Pricing controlCompetes in a buy box with other sellersYours
RulesThe marketplace's, and they changeYours, within consumer law
RiskAccount suspension stops all salesSpread across your own channels
SetupDays, once approvedWeeks, plus ongoing work to attract traffic

Neither is free. A marketplace charges you per sale. Your own store charges you for traffic, one way or another: search work, social media, email, advertising or word of mouth. We build stores in our e-commerce development work, and we still tell some clients to stay on a marketplace for now.

What do marketplace fees really add up to?

Every marketplace publishes a fee schedule, and every schedule has several layers:

  • A referral fee, a percentage of the sale price that varies by category.
  • A per-item or closing fee on each sale.
  • Shipping or fulfilment fees if the marketplace delivers for you, plus storage for stock in its warehouses.
  • Returns, which on some categories are frequent and partly at your cost.
  • Advertising, which is optional on paper and close to necessary in competitive categories.

On Amazon.com, as of October 2026, the Professional selling plan is $39.99 a month and referral fees in most categories fall between 8 and 15 percent, before fulfilment. Amazon India, Amazon.ae, Flipkart and Noon each have their own schedules. Read the current one for your category: Amazon's US seller pricing is a good example of how the layers stack.

Compare that with your own store. On Razorpay's standard plan, a domestic payment in India costs 2 percent plus 18 percent GST on the fee, as of October 2026. On Shopify Basic in the US with Shopify Payments, it is 2.9 percent plus 30 cents, plus a $39 monthly plan. Shopify fees explained has the detail.

How do you work out which earns you more?

Take one product and run both channels side by side. An illustration, with round numbers that are not any marketplace's actual rates:

Per orderMarketplaceOwn store
Sale price₹1,000₹1,000
Product cost₹450₹450
Shipping₹70₹70
Channel fees₹200 (20% in total, illustrative)₹20 (2% gateway fee)
GST on those fees (18%)₹36₹3.60
Left before marketing₹244₹456.40

The ₹212 difference is the most you can spend to bring that buyer to your own store and still match the marketplace. If a repeat customer orders three times a year, you only pay to acquire them once, and the case for your own store gets stronger with every repeat order.

Put your real costs into the profit margin calculator, and use the break-even calculator to see how many own-store orders a month cover the store's fixed costs. If you have no way to bring buyers to your own site for less than the gap, the marketplace is the better channel for now.

What do you give up on a marketplace?

The customer. The marketplace owns the relationship. You get a delivery address, not an email you can market to, and the rules forbid steering buyers to your own site.

Control of the page. Your listing sits in a template next to competitors' products and sponsored ads, sometimes for cheaper copies of what you sell.

Pricing freedom. You compete for the buy button on price, delivery speed and seller rating. Amazon's fair pricing policy can also remove your offer from the buy button if your price there is much higher than elsewhere.

Stability. Fee changes, category rule changes and account suspensions happen with short notice. A brand whose sales come entirely from one marketplace has one point of failure.

What does your own store cost you that a marketplace does not?

The build, for a start: a theme-based store with a studio costs ₹50,000 to ₹3,00,000 or $1,500 to $8,000, as of October 2026; how much an e-commerce website costs has the full ranges. Then the work a marketplace did for you: getting visitors, earning their trust without a familiar logo at the top of the page, handling payments, delivery and customer service end to end.

Of these, traffic is the one that sinks new stores. A well-built store with no visitors makes no sales. A studio can build the store, its speed, payments and search foundations; plan separately, and before launch, for how buyers will find it.

When does each make sense?

Marketplace first when you are launching a product with no brand recognition, when buyers in your category search on the marketplace rather than on Google, or when you need cash flow before you can afford to attract your own traffic.

Own store first when you sell something people seek out by name, when margins are too thin to survive marketplace fees, when you sell made-to-order or high-consideration products that need explaining, or when repeat purchase is the business model.

Both once the product sells. Use the marketplace for reach and your store for repeat buyers, bundles, the full range and the customer data. Keep stock in one pool so you do not oversell; inventory sync between your store and accounting covers how. Keep list prices aligned and give direct buyers reasons to come back that are not just a lower price.

If you decide on your own store, how to choose an e-commerce platform is the next step, and the e-commerce SEO checklist covers how to make it findable for searches the marketplace does not own.

Was this guide useful?

Questions

Frequently asked.

Can I move marketplace customers to my own store?

Not directly. Amazon and most marketplaces forbid package inserts or messages that send buyers to another site, and they hide buyer email addresses. What you can do is build a brand people remember: clear branding on the product and packaging, and a store that is easy to find when they search for you by name.

Will selling on Amazon hurt my own store's search rankings?

It can compete with them. Marketplace listings often rank well for product names, including yours. Write different, better descriptions on your own site, make sure your product pages are well structured, and expect your own site to win searches for your brand name once it is established.

Should prices be the same on the marketplace and my store?

Usually close. Amazon's fair pricing policy can remove your offer from the main buy button if your price there is much higher than elsewhere. Many brands keep list prices aligned and reward direct buyers in other ways: bundles, free gifts, loyalty points or exclusive products.

Sohail Hussain

Founder, MSH Technologies

Sohail has designed and built websites, web apps and AI products for over 12 years, for clients from Singapore-based industrial groups to early-stage SaaS startups. He writes about what actually worked.

Keep reading

Related guides.

All posts

Your next move

Like what you see? Tell us about it.

A process that takes too long, a website that undersells you, or an idea ready to take shape. Tell us where you are and we will suggest a useful next step.

India · Working with clients worldwide

Sohail, Founder, replies within 1 working day (Mon–Sat, IST). Free and no obligation.